Friday, February 5, 2010

Mars Trace Gas Missions

The detection of methane in the Martian atmosphere has made trace gas measurements at this world a priority.  The discovery implies that Mars is currently active -- methane has a short lifetime in the Martian atmosphere and must be regularly refreshed.  However, the discovery brought with it two mysteries.  First, is the source of the methane geological or biological activity?  Either would have major implications for our understanding of this planet and the latter would have major implications for our understanding of our place in the universe.  The second mystery is what is removing the methane so quickly, much more quickly than known processes could account for?  The issue of trace gases is not limited to methane.  Current plans are to explore concentrations of CO2, CO, H2O, H2O2, NO2 N2O, O3, CH4, C2H2, C2H4, C2H6, H2CO, HCN, N2S, OCS, SO2, HCl, and CO .

NASA and ESA have committed to flying a highly capable Mars Trace Gas Orbiter (MTGO) to address these questions in 2016.  To give an idea of how capable this mission will be, the two space agencies are planning on a 125 kg science payload, slightly more mass than the instruments on either the Mars Reconnaisance Orbiter and the Mars Express missions.  With launch, the mission is likely to be in the $700 - 750 M range.

This configuration does not include a high resolution imager, which is now included in the straw man instrument definition.

However, the investigation of trace gases will begin in 2012 with the Mars Science Laboratory, Curiosity.  This rover will carry a tunable laser spectrometer which will measure the atmospheric composition.  In addition to measuring the concentration of gases in the atmosphere, it will be able to measure carbon istotope in the methane.  On Earth, life preferentally uses the lighter carbon-12 isotope; a similar bias on Mars would hint at a biological origin for the methane.

The 2016 orbiter has three goals related to trace gases; in order of priority they are (from the Joint Instrument Definition Team report):

  1. "Detection of a broad suite of atmospheric trace gases and of key isotopologues; 
  2. "Characterization of the spatial and temporal variability of key species, including methane and ideally representing each family of photochemically important trace gases (HOx, NOx, hydrocarbons, etc.) and their source molecules (e.g., H2O); and 
  3. "Localization, including deriving the time histories of key species (again including, but not limited to, methane) and their possible interactions, including interactions with atmospheric aerosols and as affected by atmospheric state (temperature and the distribution of major source gases; e.g., water)." 

Achieving these goals will require measuring changes of gas concentrations as they change with time of day, season, and transport from their sources by winds.  Localization of sources is expected to be difficult given the dynamic nature of the atmosphere and changing concentrations of gases.


While the payload is justified on the basis of studying trace gases, the instrument payload will also continue climatological studies that began with NASA missions in the 2000s and carry out high resolution (1 - 2 m) imaging of the surface.  The high resolution camera expected to be carried by the orbiter is likely to be less capable than the MRO HiRISE instrument.  The former has approximately 25 kg allocated while the latter weighed in at 63 kg.  Improvements in electronics will help make up the difference, but as I understand the mass allocations, substantial portions go to the the mechanical structure.  (These imagers are essentially small telescopes.)  In order of priority, the high resolution cameras goals are resolution, color differentiation, and stereoscopic capabilities.

In addition to the science goals, the mission will deliver an ESA technology demonstration lander and provide data relay for the 2018 rover(s) and possibly later landed missions.  The mission will be jointly implemented by the two space agencies.  NASA will provide the launch vehicle (> $200M), the Electra relay package, a Ka-band (high data rate) string for the orbiter's communications subsystem, $100M for the science package, and science operations lead.  ESA will provide the spacecraft and manage the mission.  Individual European nations will also contribute towards the instrument costs. (For ESA missions, the instruments are paid for by the individual nations whereas NASA pays for the instruments in its missions.)

If MSL and MTGO substantiate the presence of trace gases tied to geological or biological activity, several types of follow up missions are possible:

  • A Mars Organics Observer could continuously image Mars from the Mars-Sun L1 Lagrange point, and would eventually pinpoint sources of trace gases to within a handful of kilometers.  This would be a Discovery class mission.  
  • Balloons could monitor trace gases from within the atmosphere at different altitudes and locations
  • Aircraft could study trace gas concentrations within a local area
  • And if sources of trace gases can be localized to within a few kilometers, rovers or static landers with deep drilling capabilities could explore these sources in detail.

Resources: 





Thursday, February 4, 2010

Cassini Mission Extended for Another Seven Years

In an expected move, NASA approved the extension of the Cassini mission for another ten years into 2017.  Called the Solstice Mission (previously referred to as the XXM mission), this extension would be an exciting new mission in its own right:
  • Over 50 flybys of Titan, 11 of Enceladus, and 12 of other moons
  • Continued observations of Saturn and its rings as the season changes from equinox to solstice
  • Twenty orbits with the periapses just outside the F ring for detailed measurements of the rings mass and structure
  • Twenty-two orbits with the periapses inside the rings and just above the atmosphere for studies of Saturn's interior (to be followed by Cassini's plunge into the atmosphere at the end of the mission)







Resources:

Press release

Presentation on Solstice Mission goals and mechanics This presentation is loaded with details on the Solstice mission.


Excellent Planetary Society discussion on the Solstice mission

Tuesday, February 2, 2010

Upcoming Lunar Exploration Plans

Just a quick link to a short article at Space Daily about upcoming plans to explore the moon with unmanned missions.  http://www.moondaily.com/reports/Moon_Exploration_is_Not_Dead_999.html

Monday, February 1, 2010

More Budget Perspective

If you are interested in policy and the budgets that support them, this post provides links to a number of other sites.  The big news in this budget proposal is on the manned exploration side, and some of the links below discuss these implications.

Before I list the links, here are a couple of more thoughts:

  • The increase in the Planetary program may be to pay for the production of plutonium-238.  Last year, Congress complained that the Department of Energy (which by U.S. law is the only agency allowed to produce these nuclear materials) was bearing the budget hit for new Pu-238 production.  The increase to next year's budget may be to move that hit to NASA (who would just funnel the funds to DOE).
  • In an e-mail discussion, Phil H. points out that the new Precursor program might fund the Lunar sample return that is currently a candidate for the next New Frontiers slot.  I think this is possible (and almost any speculation is possible right now given the scarcity of details on this new program).  However, the near Earth asteroid mission that is currently in competition would be an equally good candidate for this program.  Given that all three contenders would make excellent choices (the third is a Venus lander), I'd love to see one or more of them flown under a separate budget.
First, just for fun, check out What's up in the solar system in February 2010



Planetary Focused Discussions


The Planetary Society editorial
The Gish Bar Timeshttp://www.blogger.com/post-create.g?blogID=270899075443508100

General NASA Budget


NASA's budget site
Space.com
Discover (bad astronomy)
Space Politics (I always like to read the comments)
The Martian Chronicles
NASA Watch

Good Budget News

Summary documents for the President's proposed fiscal year 2011 (which starts this coming October) have been posted.  (For international readers, the budget will be modified by both houses of Congress, then the differences reconciled, and then the President will sign the final bill after possible negotiations with Congress.)

There are two good pieces of news.  First, the budget proposes a 10.8% budget increase for 2011 over the 2010 budget.  The the budget proposes to approximately match the inflation rate (presuming a 3% inflation rate).  If this were to continue over a decade, NASA's purchasing power would increase by approximately $1B, or almost enough to pay for a New Frontiers mission.  In a year where flat budgets are proposed for most discretionary spending, this is a substantial increase.  Depending on the priorities set in the Decadal Survey, this budget increase may have been included to begin serious funding of the Jupiter Euorpa Orbiter.





All figures in $Ms.

The second piece of good news is that the budget proposes a series of robotic precursor missions to various solar system locations.  Details on this new program are sketchy at the moment.  Science appears to be a low priority, but for many locations, even a simple camera can lead to new understanding.  It appears that the funding for these missions will come from NASA's Exploration budget, and therefore are in addition to the Planetary budget.



The proposed budget favors Earth Science and the Planetary program among NASA's science program:


Before celebrating, we should see how this proposal fares in Congress.  In a year when a lot of popular programs will be held to flat budgets, raiding programs that are targeted for increases may be popular.

More detail later as additional budget documents become available.

Presentation pages and budget figures are from http://www.nasa.gov/pdf/420990main_FY_201_%20Budget_Overview_1_Feb_2010.pdf .  Graph is based on budget figures in this presentation.